Publications

Home

Publications

"Courageous Testimonies: Upholding Justice"

Ramesh Ratan Jadhav v. State of Maharashtra & Ors.:

The Bombay High Court has upheld the conviction of a primary school teacher accused of sexually assaulting three young students in their classroom. The case highlights the vulnerabilities children face and the crucial role of the judiciary in upholding justice and safeguarding the welfare of minors. The court's meticulous scrutiny of evidence, implications for educational policies, and broader societal implications of the verdict underscore the gravity of the charges and the judiciary's role in safeguarding the rights and safety of children in educational settings. This blog delves into the case details, examining the court's findings, the implications for child safety measures in schools, and the broader societal impact of such judicial pronouncements.

Read more
Security Cheques under the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881

Introduction:

The Negotiable Instruments Act, of 1881, is an Indian legislation that regulates the law relating to negotiable instruments like promissory notes, bills of exchange, and cheques. Its primary aim is to facilitate the transfer of these instruments and ensure their smooth operation in commercial transactions. The Act provides a framework for creating, transferring, and paying these instruments, which are crucial for trade and commerce as they offer a secure and efficient payment method. It ensures that the rights and obligations of parties involved are clear and enforceable.

Read more
From Ignorance to Understanding: Educating Against LGBTQ Students Discrimination

Introduction:

LGBTQ students face significant challenges in educational settings, including discrimination, bullying, and exclusion, which can negatively impact their mental health, academic performance, and overall well-being. Despite legal protections and societal attitudes, many struggle to find acceptance and support. Creating an inclusive environment is crucial for their personal and academic development. Various stakeholders, including educators, parents, peers, non-profit organizations, and community leaders, are working to make schools more welcoming and inclusive. Governments worldwide have implemented legal provisions and landmark court rulings, setting precedents for equality and inclusion in education.

Read more
Behind Closed Doors: NEET Suicides in Kota

In 2024, a surge in student suicides in Kota, particularly among NEET aspirants, has been highlighted due to the city's high concentration of coaching institutes and intense competitive atmosphere. The city attracts thousands of students from across India each year, hoping to secure admissions into prestigious medical and engineering colleges. However, this intense academic environment has also led to a concerning rise in student suicides. This crisis highlights the urgent need for change in educational and societal systems to address the pressures faced by these students and the need for societal changes. Recently, this marks the 11th suspected student suicide in Kota this year. Last year, the city reported 26 cases of alleged student suicides. The exact reasons behind these tragic incidents are unclear, but the intense pressure and competition associated with NEET preparation are often cited as contributing factors. It’s essential to address mental health concerns and support students during such challenging times.

Read more
Cox & Kings Ltd. v/s SAP India Pvt. Ltd.

Arbitration, as a method of dispute resolution, has witnessed a significant evolution in India over the years, shaped by legislative reforms, judicial interpretations, and economic developments. The recent judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Cox and Kings Ltd. v. SAP India Pvt. Ltd. adds another milestone in this journey, clarifying the applicability and scope of the Group of Companies Doctrine in Indian arbitration jurisprudence. In this article, we delve into the background of arbitration law in India, analyze key case laws, including Cox and Kings, and provide insights into the current state and future prospects of arbitration in the country.

Read more
Donito's v/s. Domino's

Summary of the Case

The Delhi High Court recently restrained a Punjab-based food chain, "Donito's," from using a name that is phonetically and visually similar to the trademark of Domino's Pizza. The court's decision was based on the claim by Domino's Pizza that Donito's was infringing on its trademark by operating under a name that could cause confusion among consumers. Donito's was found to be operating six outlets in various regions of Punjab.

Read more
The Alarming Rise of Custodial Deaths

Recent Incidents 

Custodial deaths, a grim reflection of the misuse of power within law enforcement, have been increasingly making headlines in India. In 2022, Gujarat recorded the highest number of custodial deaths for the third consecutive year, according to the National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB). This troubling trend has sparked widespread concern and demands for systemic reforms.

Read more
Meta Faces Biometric Privacy Backlash: Texas v. Meta Platforms

Introduction

In a significant development in privacy law, the Madras High Court emphasized the need for a nationwide legal framework mandating paternity leave for biological and adoptive fathers. This observation emerged while overturning an order of desertion against a Tamil Nadu police inspector, highlighting the necessity for legal protections in evolving societal norms.

A landmark case reflecting the growing importance of legal frameworks in the digital age is the ongoing lawsuit, State of Texas v. Meta Platforms. Texas has taken legal action against Meta Platforms, Inc. (formerly Facebook, Inc.) for alleged biometric data privacy violations.

Read more
Trump’s Legal Labyrinth: The Hush Money Conviction and Its Implications for 2024

In an unprecedented move, a New York jury found former President Donald Trump guilty of 34 counts of falsifying business records, related to a $130,000 hush money payment to adult film actress Stormy Daniels. This landmark decision marks the first time a former U.S. president has been criminally convicted, adding a complex layer to Trump’s political and legal saga as he remains the Republican Party’s presumptive nominee for the 2024 presidential election.

Read more
Yuvraj Singh Sends Real Estate Firms for a Toss!

A Legal Battle and the Role of RERA

In a significant legal development, former Indian cricketer Yuvraj Singh has initiated legal action against two Delhi-based real estate firms over alleged violations of his privacy rights and delayed delivery of a dwelling unit. The legal notices, sent by the law firm Rizwan Law Associates on behalf of Singh, highlight serious grievances regarding the use of his image for promotional activities and the substandard quality of an apartment promised to him. This blog explores the background, legal implications, potential outcomes of this high-profile case, and the broader context of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 (RERA) in regulating the real estate sector in India.

 

Read more
The Tragic Porsche Crash

In the early hours of a seemingly ordinary day in Pune, the peaceful atmosphere was shattered by the screeching of tires and the crunch of metal. On that fateful day, 17-year-old Vedant Agarwal lost control of a high-performance Porsche, leading to a catastrophic accident that would resonate throughout the community. This article delves into the details of the crash, the aftermath, and the broader implications for road safety and legal accountability in India.

The Incident

The crash occurred on a busy street in Pune, a city known for its vibrant culture and bustling trac. Vedant Agarwal, driving a Porsche, was reportedly speeding well above the legal limit when he lost control of the vehicle. Eyewitnesses recounted the horrifying scene: the car careened o? the road, smashing into a row of parked vehicles before coming to a devastating halt. The impact was so severe that it left a trail of destruction, and the wreckage of the Porsche was barely recognizable and due to the crash, it led to the killing of two people named Anish Awadhiya and Ashwini Koshta.

 

Read more
The Dominance Dilemma in India's Digital Arena

In a significant legal development, tech giant Google has taken its battle to the Supreme Court against the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) order. The NCLAT had upheld the Competition Commission of India's (CCI) decision to impose a hefty penalty of Rs. 1337 crore on Google for alleged abuse of its dominant position.

Read more
Uniform Civil Code (UCC)

BRIEF SYNOPSIS:

With the advent of independence of India, a dialogue upon the Uniform Civil Code (UCC) is still a conundrum for everyone. Everyone is inquisitive to know about UCC and how can we implement it in India? Firstly let me decode UCC in simple terms for the layman viewers. The Uniform means "the same", Civil means "Public" & Code means "Law". Hence, the UCC is nothing more than "an equal law for everyone". 

Read more
A Paradigm Shift in Pakistan’s Politics: The Amendment to Elections Act 2017

In a significant move that has stirred up both debate and anticipation, the National Assembly of Pakistan recently passed a bill seeking to amend the Elections Act 2017. This proposed amendment aims to limit the disqualification of lawmakers to five years with retrospective effect. This decision holds profound implications for the political landscape of Pakistan and its legal framework. 

Read more
The Tangled Threads of Section 498A of IPC

In the vast tapestry of India's legal landscape, Section 498A of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) stands as a thread that weaves together the complex issue of domestic violence. Often referred to as the "anti-dowry law," this provision seeks to protect married women from cruelty and harassment inflicted by their husbands or in-laws. However, the implementation and interpretation of Section 498A have sparked intense debates, revealing a web of complexities that require careful examination. In this blog post, we will delve into the multifaceted nature of Section 498A, explore its historical context, analyze its impact on society, and shed light on the challenges faced in its application.

Read more
Geographical Indication: Preserving Cultural Heritage and Quality through Landmark Judgements

In a world where global trade and commercialization dominate various industries, it is crucial to protect the cultural heritage and unique qualities of products that are tied to specific geographical locations. Geographical Indication (GI) plays a significant role in safeguarding traditional practices, preserving authenticity, and ensuring the economic welfare of local communities. In this blog, we will explore the concept of Geographical Indication and delve into some landmark judgements that have shaped its significance.

Read more
A Landmark Shift: Estonia Paves the Way for Equality in Central Europe

In an extraordinary stride towards inclusivity and equality, Estonia has emerged as a vanguard of change by becoming the first country in Central Europe to legalize same-sex marriage. Nestled in the captivating landscapes of the Baltic region, Estonia's decision stands as a historic moment, reinforcing its commitment to fostering a society rooted in fairness and love. With the scheduled implementation of this ground-breaking law in 2024, Estonia sets an inspiring example for other nations, symbolizing the transformative power of progress and acceptance on a global scale.

Read more
Decoding Assignment Deeds in India

As the legal landscape evolves, it becomes increasingly important to understand the intricacies of various legal documents. In India, one such essential document is the Assignment Deed. Whether you are a lawyer, a business owner, or an individual looking to transfer rights or obligations, this informative blog will provide you with a comprehensive understanding of Assignment Deeds in India.

Read more
Bodily Autonomy; Patriarchy and Gender Discrimination

The right to freedom in Article 19 of the Constitution of Indian guarantees the freedom of speech and expression, as one of its six freedoms."Expression everything is life itself"– S.S Rushdie 

XXX vs. State of Kerala: Nudity of Female Upper Body Shouldn't Be Regarded As Sexual Or Obscene By Default by the Kerala High Court:

Read more
Pre-Nuptial Or Pre-Marital Agreements/Contracts In India?
PRE-NUPTIAL OR PRE-MARITAL AGREEMENTS/CONTRACTS ARE NOT ENFORCEABLE IN INDIA OR WE CAN SAY THAT THESE TYPES OF AGREEMENTS ARE VOID.

A pre-nuptial or Pre-Marital agreement is a contract that a couple signs before they get married. The couple who lives together by virtue of agreement also enjoys their status as live-in relationship. The legally-binding agreement helps the couple decide how their money, property, and other assets will be  divided in case of a divorce. But here is the question, whether pre-nuptial (nick name is PRENUPS) or Pre-marital agreement is permitted in India? Answer is big No. Still India does not accept such kind of agreement as equal to the status of legally solemnised marriage as per Indian Laws. Indian only recognizes form of marriage as per personal law or secular law.

Read more
Gujarat HC on abortion plea: invocation of Manusmriti
  1. Observations  made by single-judge Justice Samir Dave during the hearing.
  2. Is the invocation of Manusmriti pertinent?
  3. Have there been prior cases similar to this?
    • 3.1 July 2022
    • 3.2 August 2022
    • 3.2 December 2022
  1. Observations made by single-judge Justice Samir Dave during the hearing.

    A minor rape victim whose father filed a plea sought to end her seven-month pregnancy was informed by the Gujarat High Court that in olden times females would generally get married at the age of 14 or 15 and give birth by the time they were 17; also   asked the victim to ask her mother and grandmother about the same, and to study the Manusmriti to see such mentions.

    However, requested a medical opinion from a Rajkot hospital and scheduled a follow-up hearing for June 15.

Read more
The Show Goes On: Shemaroo's Plea for Interim Relief Against T-Series Hits a Sour Note
  1. Why did Shemaroo seek a restraining order against T-Series?
  2. What T-Series had to say about the assignment deeds granting it exclusive copyrights
  3. Setback faced by Shemaroo Entertainment Pvt. Ltd.
  1. Why did Shemaroo seek a restraining order against T-Series?

    In a captivating  legal showdown, Shemaroo Entertainment, a prominent player replica watches in the entertainment industry, recently sought a restraining order from the Bombay High Court against the renowned music label, T-Series. This legal manoeuvre was rooted in a claim of copyright infringement, raising eyebrows and curiosity among legal enthusiasts and industry observers alike. 

    The genesis of this dispute lies in the allegation put forth by Shemaroo Entertainment, asserting that T-Series has infringed upon its valuable  copyright-protected content. With a vast library of audio and video content under its purview, Shemaroo Entertainment has garnered a reputation as a leading distributor of Bollywood films, music, and other entertainment products. It is no surprise, then, that Shemaroo considers the protection of its intellectual replica horloges nederland property rights as paramount.

    Firmly believing that T-Series has unlawfully used its copyrighted material without authorization, Shemaroo took the proactive step of seeking a restraining order. Such an order, if granted, would prohibit T-Series from further utilizing Shemaroo's copyrighted content until the matter is resolved through legal proceedings. The aim of this legal action is to safeguard Shemaroo's interests and prevent any potential irreparable harm that may be caused by the continued unauthorized usage of their intellectual property.

    Shemaroo's request for a restraining order represents a significant strategic move in the chessboard of copyright disputes. It showcases their intent to protect their creative works and secure their market position in the face of alleged infringement. By seeking legal recourse, Shemaroo is asserting its rights as a copyright holder and asserting the importance of respecting intellectual property in the entertainment industry.

  2. What T-Series had to say about the assignment deeds granting it exclusive copyrights?

    T-Series has come forward with a compelling counterargument. T-Series, a prominent music label known for its extensive catalogue of songs, has refuted the allegations made by Shemaroo, primarily by challenging the validity and enforceability of the assignment deeds that supposedly granted exclusive copyrights to Shemaroo.

    T-Series has vehemently contested the authenticity and legality of the assignment deeds in question. Through its legal representatives, the music label has put forth a robust defence, claiming that the assignment deeds, upon which Shemaroo bases its claims of exclusive copyrights, are fundamentally flawed. T-Series asserts that the purported deeds do not meet the necessary legal requirements, rendering them null and void.

    In its response, T-Series has embarked on an extensive examination of the assignment deeds, meticulously dissecting each provision and technicality. The music label contends that the deeds lack the essential elements required for a valid assignment of copyrights, such as i. proper identification of the works, ii. clear transfer of rights, iii. and compliance with statutory formalities. T-Series further asserts that the alleged deeds fail to meet the high standards imposed by copyright law, making Shemaroo's claims of exclusive copyrights tenuous at best.

    Moreover, T-Series has presented evidence challenging the authenticity and execution of the assignment deeds. The music label asserts that the signatures on these documents have raised doubts regarding their legitimacy. T-Series claims that these signatures do not align with the purported signatories' customary style, casting doubt on the validity of the assignment deeds and raising suspicions of potential forgery or unauthorized use of signatures.

    T-Series' stance on the assignment deeds forms a critical pillar of its defence against Shemaroo's copyright infringement allegations. By questioning the validity and enforceability of these deeds, T-Series aims to dismantle the foundation of Shemaroo's claims, effectively challenging the very basis upon which Shemaroo asserts exclusive copyrights over the disputed content.

  3. 3. Setback faced by Shemaroo Entertainment Pvt. Ltd. in the infringement case

    The renowned entertainment company Shemaroo Entertainment Pvt. Ltd. found itself facing an unexpected setback in its copyright infringement case. The legal tussle, which has captured the attention of industry observers, recently took a downturn as Shemaroo's request for interim relief was denied by the Bombay High Court.

    Shemaroo Entertainment had sought interim relief from the court in the form of a restraining order against T-Series, alleging copyright infringement of its valuable intellectual property. The company's plea aimed to halt T-Series from further utilizing Shemaroo's copyrighted content until a final verdict could be reached. However, the court's decision to deny Shemaroo's request for interim relief marks a significant setback for the entertainment giant.

    The denial of interim relief by the court implies that Shemaroo's immediate quest to curtail T-Series' alleged unauthorized usage of its copyrighted material has been halted. The court's decision underscores the complexity of the case and the need for a thorough examination of the evidence and legal arguments presented by both parties. It also signifies the court's position that the status quo should be reloj imitacion rolex maintained until a comprehensive ruling on the copyright infringement allegations can be made.

    For Shemaroo Entertainment, this setback poses new challenges in its pursuit of protecting its intellectual property rights. The denial of interim relief means that the alleged infringement by T-Series may continue until a final judgment is reached, potentially causing further harm to Shemaroo's market position and creative works.

    Nevertheless, it is crucial to note that this setback does not determine the ultimate outcome of the case. The denial of interim relief does not diminish the validity of Shemaroo's copyright infringement claims, nor does it absolve T-Series of potential liability. The court's decision merely reflects its assessment that the situation does not warrant immediate intervention before a comprehensive examination and determination of the facts and legal arguments can be undertaken.

    The denial of interim relief sets the stage for a thorough examination of the evidence and legal arguments from both sides, ultimately leading to a final ruling on the copyright infringement allegations. It is within this forthcoming judgment that Shemaroo Entertainment hopes to regain lost ground and potentially secure the protection and enforcement of its valuable intellectual property rights.

Author- Smriti Singh
Pursuing BA LLB from NMIMS Kirit. P. Mehta School of Law, Mumbai

Read more
Navigating through the Laborious Labyrinth of Commercial Laws in India

Commercial law in India is a significant area of legal regulation that governs business transactions, partnerships, and trade activities. It plays a  crucial role in facilitating economic growth and ensuring a fair and efficient business environment. As a law student delving into the realm of commercial law in India, it is crucial to explore the most important legislations that govern business transactions and trade activities. These laws form the foundation of India's commercial legal framework and play a pivotal role in regulating the conduct of businesses. Let's delve into an in-depth analysis of some of the significant commercial laws in India.

Read more
Our Office

N-55, Sri Niwas Puri, New Delhi 110065

Email Us

ireneslegal9@gmail.com

Call Us

+91 995 378 5058

Copyright © 2023 ireneslegal.com. All Rights Reserved.